Skip to main content

Why it’s important – ‘Best By’ date on pet foods

Related News


  1. Michelle

    Within the past year or so, I have found many expired or expiring products on the shelves at a wide variety of retailers. I check absolutely everything when I purchase it, again when I bring it home, and yet again when I open the product. Alerting the store doesn’t always help, as I have witnessed the product being put right back out on the shelf. Believe it or not, I’ve started carrying a big black marker with me, taking the product up to the cashier, and circling the expiration date in front of the staff. Extreme? Maybe, but I would hate for someone’s pet to become sick when it was preventable.

    1. willette smith

      Thanks Michelle which by the way is my daughter’s name. She suggested after I told her my Pomeranian started acting differently after he ate a new dog food I had purchased for the nutritional value. She asked me if I looked at the expiration of the food. I have never thought to look at that for an animal. The best buy date was 10 years old. I love my dog. From now own checking the expiration of the dog food will be before the nutritional value of the food

  2. darlene

    it can also make a difference how food is transported & stored, especially in hot or humid parts of the country. my husband, a retired refrigerated/frozen transport driver, transported product from christmas trees to select restaurant steak all over the USA & into Canada. he transported dry dog food with temperature specification requirements as stringent as human grade foods and unloaded next to other foods shipped in non-temp controlled transports. temps inside those transports can skyrocket once they are loaded & sealed & the food inside may be in there for several days if shipped across country. we live in the hot south & there is a nearby feed store that carries some good brands at competitive prices, & moves a lot of food. you purchase & the warehouse guys deliver it to your vehicle. i ONLY buy there in winter because their warehouse is neither heated nor cooled. don’t mind it being stored @ 40 degrees in winter but spring thru fall if it’s transported uncooled & then stays in a 100 degree warehouse for a week or so before i purchase it……would you feed your kid cereal shipped & stored under those conditions?? think not.

    1. Peter

      Darlene, you make an excellent point that consumers should be thinking about as they make choices. Every consumer should be generally aware of the shelf life of the food they choose. The information is not difficult to find. And if, for example, the brand you choose has a two-year shelf life: you should be wary of food that isn’t recently produced (that is, showing a 2-year from now “best buy” or BB date). If, for example, you had the opportunity to get your chosen brand with a 2-year shelf life at a discount… and the cans had a BB date of a year out… what has happened to the cans in that one year that has already passed? They could have been transported and stored in less than ideal conditions. They could have been bought by your retailer in good faith, but stored “improperly” by suppliers (there could have been several, along the way). As you say, those cans could have been “fried” or “boiled” or “frozen” during that time.

      I’ve bought canned food with more than a year left on its BB date… but when opened, the food had a watery texture and was clearly not what it was originally or what I expected. The cats gobbled it enthusiastically. But I never used the remaining cans and am certain it was altered from what it was when it was manufactured. In the end, I had NO idea what this food had gone through in the interim between manufacture and the year since. So I won’t buy anything that isn’t just made.

  3. Sandra

    This story is why I’m so thankful for Susan and the work you do for us! Through you, I’ve learned so much about being a better pet food consumer. I know proudly only buy Primal Pet Foods Complete Frozen Raw Diets for my boy. A lot of that has to do with the fact that Primal has signed a transparency agreement/pledge with the Association for Truth in Pet Food. Their customer service department is excellent- I got a live person after just 3 rings. And the person on the other end was extremely knowledgeable about their product and was impressed by my know-how on the subject, too (thank you again, Susan!). The gentleman on the other end of the line informed me that Primal’s Frozen Diets have a 1 year shelf life (erm, freezer life, I mean). So when I go to my local mom & pop store, I know which foods are freshest based on their “best buy date.” This story is also another reminder of why I’m so fortunate to have a small mom & pop pet store literally next door to my home. They’re small- which is wonderful because they personally order, receive, and put out every single product and I’ve never come across a product on their shelf that was anywhere near the “best buy” date. Local is best!

  4. Cheryl

    My cats have turned their noses up for the second time to the wet cat food in the AM. This time I thought to check the date on the wet cat food can….and there wasn’t a date stamped on the side or the bottom. How can I tell how old it is? It did have a smell to it and others before didn’t.

  5. kasandra peres

    Just went to petco in camarillo ca. This evening and i was noticing the BB date so after 15 min searching for expired 2 big bags of dog food some dehydrated dog food and a few cat food bags were expired up to 1 1/2 ¥ears WTF … i dont pay 60-70 $ for food that is going to kill my much loved. “Fur People” so i took the bags of expired food and wanted to see how much were they discounting these expired expensive bags and the manager said ok take 10% off because thats what we get when we send them back and i said really are you even allowed to sell expired items here and she said yes it is just a suggested date not a definite i took a picture of the expired food and walked out … CONSUMER BEWARE ….

    1. willette smith

      So you can’t get your your money back????

      1. KP

        Actually, turn out you can. I ordered Petco Merrick food online, it was delivered few days ago, I now realized the bag has best by August 2017 on it. So this afternoon the Petco representative give me full refund and the chance to visit any Petco in my local area if my pet has any symptoms regarding to her recently consuming food from that bag.

Leave a Reply