Regulations for organic pet foods are non-existent.
The AAFCO Official Publication (the pet food rule book) defines the feed term ‘organic’ as a feed or feed ingredient that meets the requirements of the USDA National Organic Program – explained in federal law within Title 7 Code of Federal Regulations Part 205 (7 CFR Part 205). But…those regulations are for human food and livestock feed, not pet food.
Within 7 CFR Part 205 the word ‘livestock’ is mentioned 95 times, and the word ‘feed’ is included 88 times. (And unlike ‘feed’ laws across almost all US states which define pet food as a feed, the USDA National Organic Program defines feed as: “Edible materials which are consumed by livestock for their nutritional value.”) But the words ‘pet’ or ‘pet food’ are not mentioned, not once.
The AAFCO website states (bold added): “Organic regulations specific for pet foods are currently being developed.”
“Currently“?
In 2004, the National Organic Program decided to organize a task force “to develop
labeling standards for organic pet food“. The notice about the proposed organic pet food task force – posted in the Federal Register – stated (bold added): “The National Organic Standards Board (NOSB) at its October 12- 14, 2004, meeting recommended the formation of two ad hoc task force groups to develop draft organic standards. One task force will develop proposed production, handling, and labeling standards for food and animal feed products derived from aquatic animals. The second task force will develop proposed organic labeling standards for pet food.”
In 2008, the Organic Pet Food Task Force released their recommendations to the National Organic Program. Included within their recommendations were legal definitions of pet food and some ingredients, as well as labeling requirements of organic pet food such as the requirements for “organic” or “made with organic” statements on labels.
In 2010, the AAFCO website posted an “Update on Organic Pet Foods“, but the update was not from regulatory – instead the update was from industry (the Pet Food Institute). Within this update it stated the National Organic Program shared “that rulemaking for pet food will be included in the NOP’s priority work plan for
FY 2011.”
But organic pet food regulations were not provided in 2011, or any year since. Seventeen years have passed since the National Organic Program decided to develop labeling standards for organic pet food…but we still don’t have them.
Where does this leave organic pet food today?
The Pet Food Institute’s update from 2010 stated organic pet food rulemaking “will eliminate future confusion and contradictions.” Without any organic pet food regulations, what pet owners are left with today is confusion and potential contradictions.
Without regulations, one pet food manufacturer could interpret the existing National Organic Program federal laws one way while another manufacturer could interpret them another way. The existing laws don’t mention pet food, so basically they are free to interpret them any way they want. Significantly, without specific organic pet food regulations, regulatory authorities in pet food have nothing to enforce should regulatory disagree with a manufacturer’s interpretation of law.
Why hasn’t organic pet food regulations been written? Why the seventeen year delay?
It could be all the regulatory bodies involved.
The National Organic Program is part of the federal agency USDA (United States Department of Agriculture). But, pet food is regulated by sister federal agency FDA (Food and Drug Administration). These two ‘sisters’ don’t typically work together – each regulates within their jurisdiction careful not cross the line into the other’s jurisdiction. And then pet food also has AAFCO (Association of American Feed Control Officials) regulations which are openly accepted by FDA but not accepted by USDA.
We know the USDA believes that all meat ingredients in pet food should be inspected and passed, but FDA believes condemned meats are suitable for use in pet food. The seventeen year delay in organic pet food regulations could be directly linked to the two VERY different perspectives of pet food from two federal agencies.
Questions were sent to the USDA National Organic Program regarding regulations for organic pet foods, but they have not responded. Should they provide us some answers, they will be shared.
Regardless to why, because regulatory authorities haven’t written organic pet food laws, pet owners are forced to become private detectives to learn exactly how organic their organic pet food is. If your pet food makes organic claims, ask for documentation from the company to validate those claims.
One more thing…organic does NOT guarantee human grade.
Condemned, diseased, or even non-slaughtered organic raised livestock would be allowed into organic pet food (by FDA). As example the pet food label could claim organic chicken and that chicken could be condemned chicken.
Organic pet foods with the words “Human Grade” on the label (ignore website claims) are manufactured in a licensed human food facility, thus not only are those pet foods guaranteed to be all human grade ingredients – the organic ingredients in those pet foods would be required to meet the human food organic regulations.
Personal opinion: Somebody (USDA or FDA) needs to promptly write and implement organic pet food regulations. Further, pet food consumer opinions must be considered when these laws are developed. The 2008 Organic Pet Food Task Force did not include one consumer representative. A new task force needs to be organized that includes consumer representatives, USDA, FDA, AAFCO and industry. It’s time EVERYONE come to the table and gets this done. Pet owners have waited long enough.
Wishing you and your pet(s) the best,
Susan Thixton
Pet Food Safety Advocate
Author Buyer Beware, Co-Author Dinner PAWsible
TruthaboutPetFood.com
Association for Truth in Pet Food
Become a member of our pet food consumer Association. Association for Truth in Pet Food is a stakeholder organization representing the voice of pet food consumers at AAFCO and with FDA. Your membership helps representatives attend meetings and voice consumer concerns with regulatory authorities. Click Here to learn more.
What’s in Your Pet’s Food?
Is your dog or cat eating risk ingredients? Chinese imports? Petsumer Report tells the ‘rest of the story’ on over 5,000 cat foods, dog foods, and pet treats. 30 Day Satisfaction Guarantee. Click Here to preview Petsumer Report. www.PetsumerReport.com
Find Healthy Pet Foods in Your Area Click Here
The 2021 List
Susan’s List of pet foods trusted to give her own pets. Click Here to learn more.
Concerned
October 1, 2021 at 1:40 pm
marketing push already:
We know that how ingredients are grown and raised matters. That’s why Beyond Organic is reviewed by independent, USDA-Accredited Experts who ensure every recipe meets USDA National Organic Program Regulations.
https://www.purina.com/beyond/certified-organic-pet-food?utm_campaign=bcd-&utm_medium=cpc&utm_source=google&utm_content=&utm_term=best%20organic%20dog%20food&gclid=CjwKCAjw49qKBhAoEiwAHQVTo-cKqAFS5jqPKA1LJhumS8gu51CazIKsaiCuaXUAd-tirtZ-0NX2ohoCmcEQAvD_BwE&gclsrc=aw.ds
LS
October 1, 2021 at 1:40 pm
Excellent article.
Laurie Raymond
October 1, 2021 at 4:54 pm
What will it take to convince pet parents to learn how and then make proper food for their animals at home? How many years, how many deaths, sicknesses, deceptions, recalls is enough to get people to just take matters into their own hands? Competence is a matter of learning and adaptation. Anyone can do it. It isn’t rocket science. It’s just basic home economics-level nutrition for dogs and cats. It saps our energy being outraged. Industrial food producers do not have anyone’s real interests at heart. They don’t even have a heart.
Alexis
October 2, 2021 at 12:40 pm
This is exactly and precisely why I purchase ONLY locally sourced USDA or Oregon Tilth human-grade meats, fruits and vegetables (often directly from the farmer or grower) and prepare my dogs’ foods myself with guidance from a holistic veterinarian. A veterinarian who is far more interested in great nutrition for a healthy long life than in the horrors of “big Pharma” or even worse the pet-killing predominance of the Big Ag/Bit Chem companies’ products. And I would never ever trust Purina about ANYTHING. I once spoke with a local Purina feeds regional sales rep and directly asked about the presence of CORN due to aflatoxin concerns. He actually admitted to me that despite corn not being disclosed on the label “because your state doesn’t require complete labeling” there actually was corn – and SOY for heaven’s sake, also not disclosed, in the product. You could tell he was ashamed and uncomfortable selling a product that was slipping potentially dangerous ingredients in under the radar. Well, my state isn’t any better about labeling laws, Oregon being under the heavy thumb apparently forever from Big Ag and the chemical giants, and this incident was back in 2007 when the pet food poisoning crisis hit. That very day I contacted my vet and got the necessary information, recipes, and supplements, and never went back to commercially prepared pet food.